Develop vs Tone Enhancer
Answered
Hi,
can someone explain why there are different results when for example increasing the shadows to e.g. 65 value in the develop module vs to do the same in the Tone Enhancer Module w/o any other parameter? I would have expected they to the same, but we are able to apply this for a specific mask.
What is the reason why there is no midtone slider in the Tone Enhancer compared to the develop module? The presets adjust the midtowns with the curves filter applied instead.
Thank you for your feedback.
Kind Regards
Gerald
-
Hi Gerald, there isn't any one here who knows the answer to those questions. I'm sure the answer you'll get from support, who you should ask anyhow, is that that's the way the program was designed. There is a Midtones slider in the Local Adjustments.
0 -
" I would have expected they do the same"
Not sure that's a logical assumption. If they did exactly the same thing in exactly the same way they'd be the same tool, and there's no sense or value in that.
I think this is a bit like Saturation vs. Vibrance: they impact on the same characteristics of the image, but they don't replicate one another functionally - even if it is possible to use them to get a similar end result.
0 -
Thank you for your feedbacks. I will give a try with the support team. I am just asking as I was not able to find something on the handbook or other videos. It’s a matter of understanding and know what to do with what tool with good reasons. The tonality of the shadows is to my opinion more isolated with the Tone Enhancer tool. Kind regards Gerald
0 -
My advice is to experiment. Learn how they are different so you can apply that to your own workflow needs. I use them interchangeably as fits my needs at the moment.
0
Please sign in to leave a comment.
Comments
4 comments